5 Mac and Cheese Recipes for Dinner and Holiday Tables

These five mac and cheese recipes cover a quick dinner, a baked pan for a gathering, and a slow cooker side for a full holiday table. Start with Tini’s three-cheese version, then choose the texture and cooking method that fit your meal.

The biggest choice is what you want to scoop onto your plate. Some recipes stay soft and saucy. Others bake into a firmer dish with a browned top. You’ll find both here, with a note on what makes each one different and a link to the full recipe from its creator.

Tini’s cavatappi mac and cheese with a browned cheese topping.

Choose a mac and cheese recipe for your meal

  • For Tini’s three-cheese bake: Sugar & Soul’s feature uses corkscrew pasta, mozzarella, Colby Jack, and sharp cheddar. The listed total time is 55 minutes.
  • For cheddar and Gruyère: The Chunky Chef’s creamy baked version has layers of cheese and a listed total time of 35 minutes.
  • For a small stovetop batch: Serious Eats’ three-ingredient recipe takes about 10 minutes and makes two servings.
  • For a firm baked dish: I Heart Recipes’ Southern version uses eggs to help it hold its shape. The listed total time is 1 hour and 5 minutes.
  • For a busy holiday kitchen: The Pioneer Woman’s slow cooker version leaves the oven free. Allow 2 hours and 30 minutes, including cooking the pasta on the stove.

Those times come from the linked recipe pages. Each page has its own amounts, steps, and serving size.

Baked mac and cheese recipes for a gathering

1. Tini’s mac and cheese, featured on Sugar & Soul

Recipe credit: Tini Younger; featured by Rebecca Hubbell of Sugar & Soul.

This is the recipe that started the roundup. It pairs cavatappi, the short corkscrew pasta, with mozzarella, Colby Jack, and sharp cheddar. Evaporated milk and heavy cream go into the sauce, with smoked paprika and Dijon mustard among the seasonings.

The pasta and extra cheese go into a baking dish in layers. A brief broil finishes the top. If a scoop with melted cheese stretching from the pan is what you have in mind, start here.

Get the full Tini’s mac and cheese recipe from Sugar & Soul.

Close view of cavatappi beneath Tini’s broiled cheese topping.

2. Creamy baked mac and cheese from The Chunky Chef

Recipe credit: The Chunky Chef.

This version brings cheddar and Gruyère together in a sauce made with milk and half-and-half. It also has cheese between the layers of pasta and over the top.

It’s another option for a holiday side, with a different cheese blend from Tini’s. The recipe includes make-ahead notes, which help when you want to do some of the work before guests arrive. Add it to your list if you’re planning a baked dish around that cheddar-and-Gruyère pair.

Get the full creamy baked mac and cheese recipe from The Chunky Chef.

Creamy baked macaroni and cheese with cheddar and Gruyère.

3. Southern baked macaroni and cheese from I Heart Recipes

Recipe credit: Rosie Alexander of I Heart Recipes.

Eggs give this mac and cheese a firmer texture that holds together when served. The recipe uses elbow macaroni, evaporated milk, half-and-half, and a mix of cheeses that includes cheddar and Monterey Jack.

Choose this one when you want a set, baked side dish for a Sunday meal or holiday table. That texture is the main reason to choose it over one of the looser, saucier options in this list.

Get the full Southern baked macaroni and cheese recipe from I Heart Recipes.

Cut face of Southern baked macaroni and cheese.
Southern baked macaroni and cheese with a golden top.

Stovetop mac and cheese for a shorter cooking night

4. Three-ingredient stovetop mac and cheese from Serious Eats

Recipe credit: J. Kenji López-Alt of Serious Eats.

Macaroni, evaporated milk, and cheese make up this small batch. The pasta cooks in a small amount of water.

It makes two servings in about 10 minutes, with no oven step.

Get the full three-ingredient stovetop mac and cheese recipe from Serious Eats.

Three-ingredient stovetop mac and cheese with a creamy sauce.

Slow cooker mac and cheese when the oven is full

5. Slow cooker mac and cheese from The Pioneer Woman

Recipe credit: Ree Drummond of The Pioneer Woman.

The slow cooker makes the sauce for this version, which uses cheddar, Monterey Jack, American cheese, and cream cheese. The pasta cooks separately on the stove and joins the sauce near the end.

That detail helps with planning: you’ll still need a pot for the pasta, while the oven can hold the rest of the meal. The recipe lists 8 to 10 servings, making it a useful choice for a gathering.

Get the full slow cooker mac and cheese recipe from The Pioneer Woman.

Creamy macaroni and cheese served from a slow cooker.

Make it part of dinner

Mac and cheese can be the main dish with a salad or green vegetable alongside it. For a larger meal, a baked pan can sit beside roast chicken, ham, or pulled pork.

If you’re filling in the rest of the week, these weeknight dinner ideas give you more meals to choose from.

For the serving pieces and tools around a gathering, browse these kitchen finds for feeding people.

Questions about these mac and cheese recipes

What cheeses are in Tini’s mac and cheese?

The Sugar & Soul version uses mozzarella, Colby Jack, and sharp cheddar. It layers some of that cheese with the pasta before baking.

Which recipe can you make without an oven?

The Serious Eats stovetop recipe has no baking step. The Pioneer Woman’s version uses a slow cooker for the sauce and a pot for the pasta.

Which recipe has a firmer texture?

The Southern baked version from I Heart Recipes uses eggs to help the dish set. Choose it when you want portions that hold their shape on the plate.

Can you prepare baked mac and cheese ahead?

Both Sugar & Soul and The Chunky Chef include make-ahead notes. Follow the notes for the recipe you choose, since the baking time changes when the dish starts cold.

Does slow cooker mac and cheese cook entirely in one pot?

The Pioneer Woman recipe in this roundup cooks the pasta separately. Keep that step in your meal plan when choosing which burners and appliances you’ll need.

Next
Next

18 Highly Rated Soup Recipes for Dinner